Tuesday, June 28, 2011
In a review of ex-newspaper exec James O'Shea's book The Deal From Hell: How Moguls and Wall Street Plundered Great American Newspapers Slate says "he appears to make the reportorial mistake of coming to conclusions first and not letting the evidence, no matter how strong, shake him loose from them."
"In O'Shea's view, the cause of the undoing of the newspapers owned by the Tribune Co. and Times Mirror, as well as other newspapers in the country, has not been the Internet, or declining circulation, or long stories and 'skimpy attention spans, or arrogant journalists.' It's been the reaction of newspaper executives to those forces. He writes: 'The lack of investment, the greed, the incompetence, corruption, hypocrisy, and downright arrogance of people who put their interests ahead of the public's are responsible for the state of the newspaper industry today.'
"The problem with O'Shea's analysis is that important newspapers whose executives and owners weren't stingy, greedy, incompetent, corrupt, hypocritical, or arrogant have also been forced to reduce news pages, cut whole sections, close bureaus and decimate newsrooms.
"Both the Washington Post and the New York Times, long controlled by families that have taken immense pride in providing the public service of great journalism, have bent before recent market forces and made the cuts that O'Shea deplores," Slate writes before concluding:
"O'Shea, an experienced reporter and editor, misses the story and writes poorly. If only we could send his terrific assignment back to the rewrite desk for fixing."
Click on the title to read the whole review.
- ► 2019 (47)
- ► 2018 (137)
- ► 2017 (183)
- ► 2016 (278)
- ► 2015 (321)
- ► 2014 (262)
- ► 2013 (365)
- ► 2012 (644)
- OWL survives in a challenged magazine world
- Shaw cancels plans to launch sports network; repor...
- Confidence In TV News and Newspapers (Slightly) Up
- The perils of reality TV: Is an election candidate...
- Sun News interview with dancer drew record complai...
- Slate magazine quarrels with author's analysis of ...
- Israel rescinds threat to reporters on flotilla
- CNN Sportscaster Nick Charles Dies
- CTV Toronto, CP 24 among RTNDA award winners
- Is the N.Y. Times taking itself too seriously in t...
- Star's public editor on unpaid "internships"
- Former Sportsnet host files human rights complaint...
- Conrad Black sentenced to 13 more months
- ‘Dragons’ Den’ star Kevin O’Leary accused of ‘enco...
- Apple planning "Apple branded" TV next year: Analyst
- CHCH morning show to begin at 4 am
- Gannett cuts 700 jobs across Midwest
- Olbermann beats Spitzer for young demo
- BCE says any ban on exclusivity ‘preposterous’
- Barnes & Noble Loss in Digital Books
- Rogers upset by "Wild West" of new media
- Billboard to tell drivers what music is playing
- Vertical vertigo in Hull
- Student's prom dress made of old newspapers
- The America’s Cup, Translated for Television
- Kissing couple tell story to the CBC
- Lovers kiss off New York media offers
- Painful re-telilng of a painful prediction
- Only in Argentina -- media heirs forced give DNA
- Media on the hunt for Vancouver riots hero
- Rogers names Whyte to head publishing unit
- Lloyd Robertson to release memoir in fall 2012
- CBC prepares to defend its finances
- Damascus hoax shows how easy it is to manipulate n...
- Australia's largest newspaper publisher refuses to...
- Fifth Estate wins Michener award for Ashley Smith ...
- HuffPost review: Page One -- Inside the New York T...
- Conservatives 'lay track' to attack media, real op...
- Facebook use drops in Canada, U.S.
- CRTC chief talks legislation for services such as ...
- Billionaire Russian immigrant buys 20 per cent sta...
- Montreal-based Reuters photog, Shaun Best, dead at 43
- The Internet is killing local news, U.S. regulato...
- Scottish newspapers in crisis just when they are n...
- MoneySense named Magazine of the Year (print) at N...
- Rogers to launch Sportsnet magazine
- Huffington Post trumps NY Times’ web traffic
- Texas body hoax -- the lofty Euro view
- Officer who bullied reporter to be docked pay
- Toronto Star to buy online beauty magazine The Kit
- News of the World apologises to Sienna Miller
- Robertson to anchor last CTV newscast Sept. 1
- Apple upset that AP is working on Jobs obit
- iPad Daily:"Nobody Knows Anything"
- Is the war on drugs really a war on journalists?
- L.A. Times columnist comments on the task ahead to...
- The New York Times appoints first woman editor
- TV broadcasters return to profitability but employ...
- Christie Blatchford jumps back to National Post
- Quebecor to launch all-sports channel this fall
- ▼ June (60)
- ► 2010 (1055)